Ohio’s Policy Wastes Money and Lives
Cleveland Plain Dealer - September 20, 2002
by Blaine Griffin, in The Cleveland Plain Dealer
A recent Plain Dealer story documented citizens’ con cerns about the
costs of drug treatment for nonviolent offenders. But in Ohio we pay far
more, in cash and in lost opportunity, when we send nonviolent
offenders to prison.
Prison spending ballooned by more than one billion inflation-adjusted
dollars between 1985 and 2000. Just 15 years ago, we got by on a
corrections budget of less than $200 million. Ohio’s current approach
makes no sense, fiscally or morally.
We’ve quadrupled the number of people in Ohio’s prisons over the last 25
years. Much of the new incarceration is for nonviolent crimes. Only six
states have a higher rate of nonviolent, drug-related admissions.
We incarcerate more than three times as many black men for nonviolent drug
crimes as we used to. By 1996, 40 percent of black men who entered Ohio’s
prison system were jailed for nonviolent offenses. I see the results of these
policies first hand, in my family, through my work at East End Neighborhood
House, and in my community.
Nonviolent offenders emerge from prison facing many of the same
barriers that hardened felons confront. Ex-convicts are less likely to
finish their education, less likely to get decent-paying jobs, more
challenged in being good parents and partners, and more accustomed
to a violent or criminal culture. This leads to recidivism and deterioration
of our family and community infrastructure. These devastating trends
are a threat to the future of our culture and the foundations of America.
If the human cost of this doesn’t bother you, the financial costs should.
Our billion-dollar prison budget limits our ability to fund other services
that would contribute to, instead of detracting from, our economy. Our
corrections budget has grown 5.5 times faster than our higher education
budget at a time when a college degree is becoming more essential to
The monumental 213 percent increase in black men locked up for drug
crimes over the last two decades has resulted in Ohio’s prisons
reporting more black male inmates of all ages (23,200) than our colleges
and universities report having as students (20,074). These numbers are
shocking, but they’re also accurate. In his Sept. 4 column, (“Distorted
images from distorted facts”) Sam Fulwood expressed concern about
the faulty assumptions that could be drawn from these statistics. But
unless we talk about these numbers, we can’t expect them to change.
Go to any barbershop to find the human faces that confirm these
numbers. The number of intelligent men who lack opportunities because
they are “on papers” or have a “number” because of nonviolent crime is
astounding. We are losing our brothers, sons and fathers. This is an
issue that the African-American community must move to the top of our
Higher education is a much smarter place to invest than prison. But
Ohio hasn’t learned that lesson. We rank 39th in the percentage of
adults who can claim a bachelor’s degree. And we’re 10th from the top
in the price of a college education.
For the $22,000 average annual prison price tag for one person, we
could send four to an Ohio public university.
Ohio can and must do better by its citizens. Nonviolent drug offenders
need treatment, which costs far less than prison. Students need
affordable universities. Employers need a more educated work force.
We can afford all three if we just recognize that we are not the prisoners
of our misguided policies.
Griffin is program manager and grant writer for the East End
Neighborhood House. He is also on the board of directors at Policy
Matters Ohio, which recently released “Cellblocks or Classrooms,” a
report on prison and higher education spending in Ohio. The report is
available on the Web site, www. policymattersohio.org
Full Article (PDF version)