To receive updates and stay connected to Policy Matters Ohio, sign up here!

Research & Policy
Policy Matters Ohio

It’s official: 2019 worst year for Ohio jobs since recession

March 06, 2020

It’s official: 2019 worst year for Ohio jobs since recession

March 06, 2020

Jobs also decline in January 2020

The numbers: Revised data released today by the Ohio Department of Job and Family Services (ODJFS) show that Ohio employers added just 18,300 jobs in 2019. This is a downward revision from an already weak initial report in January. Based on the new data, 2019 remains Ohio’s worst year for job growth since the end of the Great Recession. The federal Bureau of Labor Statistics and ODJFS benchmark total nonfarm payroll employment to state unemployment insurance tax records in March. This often results in marked revisions to the jobs data reported earlier. The new data show Ohio’s job growth rate was just 0.3% last year. The national rate was 1.4%. All figures are seasonally adjusted.

It’s official: 2019 worst year for Ohio jobs since recession

Photo by Steve Cagan

Today’s report also shows that 2020 is off to a challenging start. Preliminary numbers show that Ohio employers cut 6,300 jobs in January and 12,500 jobs since January of last year. This suggests a continued weakening of the Ohio labor market.

  • Manufacturers cut 6,000 jobs from January 2019 to January 2020. Mining and logging firms cut 800 jobs. Construction firms added 1,600 jobs, reducing overall losses in goods-producing industries to 5,200 jobs.
  • Service sector employment rose 4,900 as gains in private education and health services (+10,600), and leisure and hospitality (+2,300) outweighed losses in professional and business services (-7,400) and trade, transportation and utilities (-1,200).
  • Cutbacks made by state and local policymakers cost Ohio 12,200 public sector jobs, including 8,500 state and 4,900 local jobs. The federal government added 1,200 jobs in Ohio.
  • The unemployment rate, which is determined by a separate survey of households also released today by ODJFS, remained unchanged from December at a low 4.1%. The number of Ohioans working or actively seeking work also improved slightly, increasing by 6,000. Overall, the household survey shows that there are 168,200 fewer Ohioans working or looking for work now than there were before the 2007 recession. U.S. unemployment crept up a tenth of a point to 3.6% in January - still very low.

What it means: Policy Matters Ohio researcher Michael Shields said, “Today’s state jobs report is a disappointment even in light of low initial estimates of 2019 growth. These new data suggest the Ohio economy is continuing to slow. Manufacturing jobs fell, and what growth we saw was in service industries including many lower-paying jobs. Meanwhile, state and local governments slashed 13,400 of the jobs they have most control over.

Why it’s happening: “Years of tax cuts have not resulted in the promised private sector investment that would pull more Ohioans back into the workforce, especially into high quality jobs. But they have cost our schools and communities vital investments. Now cuts to state and local government jobs have reduced year-over-year Ohio employment through January. Only the service sector, which includes many low-wage jobs, is growing.” Shields said.

Two solutions: Ohio policymakers have misspent 10 years of economic growth on tax cuts for the wealthy instead of preparing for the next recession and making Ohio a state where everyone can thrive. With signs the expansion is now slowing, Shields said Ohio needs to set a wiser course.

  • Policymakers must protect Ohio’s unemployment compensation benefits from cuts and strengthen the system by expanding eligibility to more of Ohio’s low-wage workers.
  • Ohio has a shared work program that enables employers to reduce layoffs by distributing hour reductions across many workers and permitting those workers to make a partial claim on unemployment benefits to replace their lost wages. The state needs to inform and encourage employers to develop shared work plans to avert as many layoffs as possible.


2020JobWatchMichael ShieldsWork & Wages

Share This


Photo Gallery

1 of 22

To receive updates and stay connected to Policy Matters Ohio, sign up here!


No Thanks, Please don't ask again.