To receive updates and stay connected to Policy Matters Ohio, sign up here!

Submit
Research & Policy
Policy Matters Ohio

How Ohio (under)funds childcare

September 11, 2024

How Ohio (under)funds childcare

September 11, 2024

Funding for Ohio’s childcare system is complicated, even to the most seasoned advocates. It became even more so in Fiscal Year (FY) 2024-25 budget, when House Bill 33[1] created a new Department of Children and Youth (DCY), changing federal and state funding streams for Publicly Funded Child Care (PFCC) and early education programs.

The Department of Children and Youth

Using the FY2024-25 budget, the legislature made multiple changes to Ohio’s childcare system.[2] The new Department of Children and Youth (DCY) was formed by splitting off some child- and family-related programming from the Ohio Department of Job and Family Services (ODJFS), which received a major cut to their state-share operating budget as a result.[3] Many of the ODJFS programs in early childhood and childcare were consolidated in the newly created DCY.

For the department’s first year of operation, FY24, the legislature appropriated $753.4 million from the Main Operating Budget, increasing to $761.8 million in FY25. In total (state, dedicated purpose funds, and federal funds), the new department will operate at $2.25 billion in FY24 and $2.26 billion in FY25, nearly half of which goes to childcare.[4]

DCY will house PFCC and other child- and youth-related services, such as kinship care,[5] the Ohio Children’s Trust Fund,[6] and foster care programs[7] taken from other departments. These include the Ohio Department of Health (DOH), Ohio Department of Education and Workforce (ODEW), Ohio Department of Mental Health and Addiction Services (OHMAS), Ohio Department of Development (DEV), and Ohio Department of Developmental Disabilities (DODD).[8]

How Ohio pays for Publicly Funded Child Care

Ohio allocated $1.1 billion total to childcare funding in FY24 (49% of DCY’s overall budget), with state dollars accounting for less than a quarter ($265.28 million) and $834.90 million in federal funding from the Child Care Development Block Grant[9] and TANF Funds.[10]

Figure 1

State funding for PFCC comes from the General Revenue Fund (GRF) and through the Maintenance of Effort (MOE) funds attached to each federal block grant. To receive the TANF block grant from the federal government, most states must meet a MOE requirement equal to 80% of what they spent in federal FY 1994.[11] That amounts to $416.9 million for Ohio in FY23. Because some TANF funds are used for other programs still handled by ODJFS, those funds are split between ODJFS and DCY.[12]

Key terms

General Revenue Fund (GRF): The fund that holds most of the state's annual tax revenue each year. Most state budget spending comes from the GRF.

FY24-25: Fiscal Year (FY) refers to the period during which the funds are to be spent. Because Ohio’s budgets span two years, FYs are usually paired (FY24-25) in budget tables. Ohio’s FY runs from July 1 of that year to June 30 of the following year. For example, Ohio’s FY24 began on July 1, 2023 and runs through June 30, 2024.

(Year) Actuals: In a budget table, the term actuals describes the amount of funds raised in the previous year for a line item. This can be a good indicator of whether the state is raising enough funds to support a program. It’s often used as a benchmark to allocate the next two years' funding.

Appropriation Line Item (ALI): Six-digit number used in budget documents to track funding line items. The first three numbers indicate the agency or division; the last three numbers identify the object of expenditure.

Greenbook: The final analysis of the budget done by the Legislative Service Commission after every budget cycle. These are organized by department.

Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF): Federal program that gives states money to support families in poverty. States choose how to use these funds in their budgets and programming.

The state combines federal funds and state dollars in MOE funds to pay for the full PFCC program. For example, the Early Care and Education line item (ALI 830500), which provides funding for families who are eligible for PFCC and have incomes ranging from 201% to 300%[13] of the federal poverty level (FPL), counts toward TANF MOE requirements.[14] These funds supplement the actual TANF Funds (ALI 830605), which only cover people whose incomes fall under 200% FPL.[15]

Ohio’s Publicly Funded Child Care system by line item

Childcare funding supports all parts of the system, from childcare workers' paychecks to providers’ licenses, to program administration. Ohio’s PFCC funding stream is complex, comprising seven separate line items: three drawing from the GRF, two from Dedicated Purpose Funds (DPFs),[16] and two from federal block grants.

Much of the funding pays for services, such as reimbursement for providers. The two DPFs fund specific initiatives by the administration to support infrastructure projects for programs and the Step Up to Quality Program (SUTQ).

State-share funds

  • Child Care State/Maintenance of Effort (MOE)(GRF ALI 830400) is funded at $187.27 million for FY2024-25, with FY24 funding up 12.4% from the previous fiscal year. This line item provides GRF payments to PFCC. The line item is double counted toward MOE requirements for TANF and the Child Care Development Block Grant (CCDBG), which is the primary Federal funding mechanism for child care in Ohio.[17]
  • Child Care Licensing (GRF ALI 830409) is funded at $6 million for FY2024-25, a 39.8% increase from FY23. These funds are used to license and inspect preschool and school-age childcare programs.[18]
  • Early Care and Education (GRF ALI 830500) is funded at $282.57 million for FY2024-25. The FY24 allocation is slightly lower than in FY22-23, and a more substantial cut when inflation is considered. This line item is used to support PFCC services and payments, including for families whose income eligibility is 201% to 300% FPL.[19] The line item also includes Step Up to Quality (SUTQ) enhancements. The state counts this line item toward its MOE requirements.
  • Early Childhood Education (GRF ALI 830407) is funded at $260.63 million over the biennium. This line item funds Early Childhood Education (ECE) programs — commonly referred to as ECE grants — at K-12 schools, community schools, and other licensed childcare centers for families at or below 200% of the Federal Poverty Line (FPL).[20]

State Dedicated Purpose Funds

  • Child Care Infrastructure Grants (5AK1[21] ALI 830614) is funded at $30 million over FY24-25. This new line item was introduced in HB 33, targeted toward childcare for infants and toddlers in communities with high infant mortality rates.[22]
  • Early Childhood Education (5KT0[23] ALI 830606) is funded at $26 million for FY24-25. The FY24 appropriation is 35.00% lower than the appropriation for FY23, because the fund does not replenish. This line item supports the Step Up to Quality program (SUTQ) and other administrative costs.[24]

Federal-Share Funds

  • Child Care (3H70 ALI 830604) is funded at $1.19 billion over FY24-25. This federal line item is used to disperse the Child Care and Development Fund dollars. The Block grant experienced some fluctuation from FY22-23 due to federal pandemic aid changes, but is now back to comparable FY22 funding levels.[25] The fund’s MOE for the Child Care and Development Block Grant in FY23 is $45.4 million and can be double counted toward the TANF MOE (which Ohio does).[26]
  • TANF Block Grant (3V60 ALI 830605) is funded at $480.26 million over FY24-25. This is the DCY portion of the TANF block grant, while the remainder of the block grant is allocated through ODJFS. The DCY TANF money is used for PFCC payments for families under 200% of FPL.[27]

Additional funding notes

  • If you noticed the Early Childhood Education (ALI 830606) and Early Childhood Education (ALI 830407) had the same name – you're right! Then, Early Care and Education (GRF ALI 830500) adds a third similar name. All three of these funds cover either PFCC or ECE child care programs.
  • As of 2021, the state of Ohio was reporting a TANF underspend of $619 million.[28] As of publication, the TANF underspend has not been updated for 2024.[29] The TANF underspend — which includes the previous year’s unused Block Grant funds that have accrued over time and not yet been spent or set aside for a dedicated purpose — are being used toward the state’s childcare spending.[30]

[1] HB 33 is Ohio’s FY2024-25 Main Operating Budget. See Legislative Service Commission (LSC) for details.

[2] A 2022 LSC report detailed the previous funding streams to PFCC.

[3] This cut was a decrease in state-share appropriation of 41.7% from FY23 to FY24, a difference of $401 million. FY23 are in the 134th General Assembly Greenbook, p. 5. FY24 numbers are in the 135th GA Greenbook, p. 4.

[4] FY2024-25 funding can be found in the DCY Greenbook.

[5] Kinship care is a program that gives payments to families where a child is being taken care of by a related adult, like a grandparent. The Kinship Guardian Assistance Program (KGAP) (Earmarked under ALI 830603) and Kinship Permanency Incentive (ALI 830501) Program are examples.

[6] The Ohio Children’s Trust Fund was created in 1984 and is the state’s primary funding agent for programs designed to prevent child abuse and neglect. It is funded through state (1980 ALI 830600) and federal (3D30 ALI 830602) line items. See page 13 of the DCY Greenbook for more.

[7] Foster Care Programs can be found at C:2: Foster and Substitute Care on page 9 of the DCY Greenbook.

[8] A summary of programs moving to the department is in the Ohio Job and Family Services Greenbook, p.1.

[9] The Child Care Development Block Grant (CCDBG) is a federal program reauthorized in 2014. As of 2023, the block grant was funded at $8.02 billion after significant funding increases beginning in FY18. Since then, the CCDBG has gained $5.12 billion in funds.

[10] TANF is the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families federal block grant program. For more information, see the congressional TANF Primer (2023). Information about the Child Care Block Grant (ALI 830604) and TANF Block Grant (ALI 830605) are in the DCY Greenbook (p. 16-17).

[11] Maintenance of Effort (MOE) amounts refer all the way back to TANF‘s establishment in 1994. A state’s MOE requirement must be equal to 80% of what a state spent on its program in 1994. If the state meets certain workforce participation requirements, MOE is reduced to 75% of 1994 spending. Ohio meets the requirements for reduced spending but does still maintain 80% funding. For more on MOE requirements, see this report. For more on Ohio’s MOE see p. 8 in the ODJFS Greenbook.

[12] Ohio double counts MOE for TANF toward the Child Care Development Block Grant, since the funds are used to meet the purposes of both programs.

[13] To enroll children in PFCC, Ohio families must have an annual income at or below 145% FPL. Once enrolled, they remain eligible as their income increases, up to 300% FPL. Policy Matters advocates raising enrollment eligibility to 300% as well.

[15] See TANF Block Grant (3V60 ALI 830605) on p. 17 of the DCY Greenbook.

[16] DPFs are pots of money set aside for specific purposes, separate from the General Revenue Fund. A complete list of is in the Detailed Appropriations Summary by Fund (2023).

[17] This line item includes two Child Care Development Block grants. The Child Care Development Fund is the source of funds, while specific grants within the program go toward specific goals. Funds for these activities were previously in GRF line item 600413, under ODJFS. See p. 15 of the DCY Greenbook for more.

[18] Funds for Child Care Licensing activities were previously in GRF line item 200442, under the Department of Workforce and Education. For more information see the DCY Greenbook (p. 15).

[19] This line item was previously in GRF line item 600535, under the Ohio Department of Job and Family Services. More information on this line item can be found in the DCY Greenbook, p. 15-16.

[20] Early Childhood Education grants (ECE) is not considered PFCC, therefore it is not included in PFCC-related calculations in this paper. We include it in this list for clarity because it does serve children and is a key part of Ohio’s early education childhood programs. This was previously ALI 200408, Early Childhood Education, under DEW.

[21] This DPF group is funded by a transfer from the GRF year ending balance. See the Catalog of Budget Line Items (COBLI), p. 130.

[22] Grants may be used to provide workforce supports, technical assistance, facilities improvement, and classroom supplies. For details, see the DCY Greenbook, p. 16.

[23] This DPF group is funded by money paid to the state by casino operators. See COBLI, p. 131.

[24] Funds for these activities were previously in Fund 5KT0 line item 600696, under ODJFS. See DCY Greenbook, p. 16.

[25] In FY22, the Child Care Federal line item was funded at $540.5 million. After changes due to federal aid and American Rescue Plan Act Funds, it is now at $594.5 for FY24. This is an increase of 9.99%. For more information, see both the HB110 ODJFS Greenbook, p. 19, and the HB33 DCY Greenbook, p.16.

[27] The DCY Greenbook (p. 17-19) includes an extensive section detailing TANF Funds in relation to PFCC.

[30] An ODJFS Program Services Framework for SFY 2024-2027 estimates that by FY27 the sustainability balance brought forward will fall to $291.28 million while PFCC – TANF Funds will rise to $542.95 million.

Tags

2024Budget PolicyChild careRevenue & Budget

Share This

Close

Photo Gallery

1 of 22

To receive updates and stay connected to Policy Matters Ohio, sign up here!

Submit

No Thanks, Please don't ask again.